arubis

Review: maddy-spf-dkim-domain-migration v30

Task UUID: a4bc3f9c-fe11-4473-960c-2717c39f2417 Version: v30 (2026-04-06) Backend: biggie-nebula (teapot) Reviewer: Dylan Fitzgerald Prior review: v18 (2026-04-02)

---

arubis

Task Review: Jaeger Query Service Index Mapping Conflict

Task ID: jaeger-query-service-indexmapping-conflict UUID: 378d049f-e957-4c78-9fa8-d1b84684d37e Version: 12 Author: chrorrala (Christian Orrala) Category: Platform Engineering Reviewer: Dylan Fitzgerald Date: 2026-04-03

arubis

Jaeger Query Service Index Mapping Conflict — Difficulty Recommendations

Task	378d049f (v12) by Christian (chrorrala)
Backend	Docker
Threshold	mean < 0.50
Current mean	0.64 (7 biggie-nebula runs)
Verdict	NEEDS_WORK

arubis

Task Review: Jaeger Query Service Index Mapping Conflict

Task UUID: 378d049f-e957-4c78-9fa8-d1b84684d37e Task ID: jaeger-query-service-indexmapping-conflict Category: Platform Engineering Author: chrorrala Eval version: v12 (local files: v11 — API 500'd on download) Backend: Docker (author confirmed in Discord: "I reverted to the normal docker as instructed") Reviewer: Dylan Fitzgerald

arubis

Task Review: rabbitmq-amqp-dead-fanout (v12)

UUID: 71d0a7da-2d8e-465e-b3f5-d2e50c6ea3bb Author: peterkay_86616 Category: cloud-ops Backend: Teapot (threshold: ≤0.85)

---

Verdict: APPROVE

arubis

Review: maddy-spf-dkim-domain-migration

Task UUID	a4bc3f9c-fe11-4473-960c-2717c39f2417
Version	19
Thread	https://discord.com/channels/1427397917685321919/1487685828166553737
Review date	2026-04-02

Verdict: NEEDS_WORK

arubis

Review: alertmanager-webhook-routing-failure v10

Verdict: NEEDS_WORK | Mean score 0.96 (threshold: <0.50 docker backend) | 8 of 9 scored runs perfect 1.0

---

Why It's Too Easy

Every fault follows the same diagnostic loop:

arubis

Task Difficulty Tuning

A systematic process for adjusting AI agent task difficulty when scores are too high (task too easy) or too low (task too hard).

For acceptance criteria and pass rate thresholds, see Task Review Guide. For failure analysis methodology, see Task Eval Analysis.

When to Use

• Task scoring above target threshold (>70% pass rate - too easy)
• Task scoring below target threshold (0% but solution works - artificial failures)

arubis

"""Grader for postgres-cve-2024-7348-pg-dump-privesc.

Checks:
  1. version_remediated   — PostgreSQL image is >= 16.4 (not 16.3 or earlier)
  2. search_path_hardened — POSTGRES_OPTIONS env var no longer sets unsafe search_path
  3. deployment_healthy   — Deployment has desired replicas ready
  4. database_reachable   — PostgreSQL responds to a basic health query
"""

import subprocess

arubis

ArgoCD Resource Hook Deadlock — Task Review

Task: 9cd2b86e-15bf-4c76-8685-efffd1114c8f
Version: v16
Task ID: argocd_hook_reconciliation_deadlock
Category: platform-eng
Author: hafis_83579
Reviewer: Dylan (primary)
Discord: https://discord.com/channels/1427397917685321919/1483534668413407262