Original thread; https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/denominator-dev/aOtc4r9TLTI
Just wanted to chime in with some brief suggestions.
I think the proposals are both ambiguous about the precedence applied between weighting and geo selection. Some providers support just one precedence order between weighted and geo, some support both, and obviously we can never predict what future providers may support.
Geo->Weighted as a use-case makes intuitive sense, a good example is routing everyone on the East coast of the US to a datacenter on the east coast, but then balancing load across multiple endpoints "within" that selection. I think all the providers support this precedence order today.