I prepared a risk analysis that identifies significant governance, legal, and privacy concerns with the proposed on-chain implementation of the Ambassador Fellowship. This executive summary outlines these risks and highlights critical questions that should be addressed before implementation.
The purpose of this risk assessment is twofold: 1) Polkadot OpenGov Pull Request #736 implements only a simplified subset of the full Ambassador Fellowship Manifesto previously approved by OpenGov, potentially requiring new approval; and 2) the Polkadot Ambassador Fellowship Governance Extension Pallet I've developed implements critical manifesto components missing from PR #736, but requires proper governance foundations to be effective. Addressing these concerns before implementation would:
- Increase Approval Likelihood: Demonstrate thorough risk assessment and mitigation planning, showing OpenGov voters that governance