Coordinators & StateMachine - Concept

Coordinator.swift

struct Coordinator {
  let window: UIWindow
  let navCtrl: UINavigationController?
  
  func start() {
    presentWelcomeScreen()
  }
  
  private func presentWelcomeScreen() {
    let vc = WelcomeScreenViewController() // Instanciate from code, XIB, Storyboard, whatever your jam is
    vc.navTransitions = WelcomeScreenTransitions(
      showHome: self.pushHomeScreen, // see private func below
      showCreateAccountScreen: self.pushCreateAccountScreen
    )
    window.rootViewController = vc // or whatever
  }
  
  private func pushHomeScreen(user: User?) {
    let vc = HomeScreenViewController() // Instanciate from code, XIB, Storyboard, whatever your jam is
    vc.user = user // or inject a ViewModel here if you're doing MVVM, you get the idea
    
    vc.navTransitions = HomeScreenTransitions(
      showUserInfoScreen: {
        // From Home, we *push* the UserInfoVC
        self.navigationController.pushViewController(instanciateUserInfoScreen(user), animated: true, completion: nil)
      }
      showProductDetail: self.pushProductDetail // extracted in private function below
      disconnectAndShowLoginScreen: self.presentLoginScreen // same
    )
    
    navCtrl = UINavigationController(rootViewController: vc)
    window.rootViewController = navCtrl
  }
  
  private func pushProductDetail(product: Product) {
    let vc = ProductDetailViewController() // Instanciate from code, XIB, Storyboard, whatever your jam is
    vc.product = product // inject any object to the VC, like a ViewModel or whatever
    
    vc.navTransitions = ProductDetailTransitions(
      showUserInfoScreen: {
        // But from ProductDetail VC, we *present* the UserInfoVC *modally*
        self.presentViewController(instanciateUserInfoScreen(product.owner), animated: true, completion: nil)
      }
      back: { navCtrl?.popViewController(animated: true) }
    )
    
    navCtrl?.pushViewController(vc, animated: true) { _ in }
  }
  
  private func pushCreateAccountScreen() {
    // Create and push a CreateAccountViewController and its CreateAccountTransitions struct
    ...
  }
  
  private func instanciateUserInfoScreen(user: User) -> UIViewController {
    // Create, configure and return an UserDetailsViewController
    ...
  }
}

HomeScreenViewController.swift

struct HomeScreenTransitions {
  let showUserInfoScreen: Void -> Void
  let showProductDetail: Product -> Void
  let disconnectAndShowLoginScreen: Void -> Void
}

class HomeScreenViewController: UIViewController {
  var navTransitions: HomeScreenTransitions!
  
  @IBAction func profileAction(_: AnyObject) {
    navTransitions.showUserInfoScreen()
  }
  
  @IBAction func disconnectAction(_: AnyObject) {
    confirm("Are you sure?") {
      navTransitions.disconnectAndShowLoginScreen()
    }
  }
  
  @objc func tableView(tableView: UITableView, didSelectRowAtIndexPath: NSIndexPath) {
    let product = productsDataSource[indexPath.row]
    navTransitions.showProductDetail(product)
  }
}

ProductDetailViewController.swift

struct Product {
  let id: Int
  let owner: User
  ...
}

struct ProductDetailTransitions {
  let showUserInfoScreen: Void -> Void
  let back: Void -> Void
}

class ProductDetailViewController: UIViewController {
  var navTransitions: ProductDetailTransitions!
  
  @IBAction func showProductOwner(_: AnyObject) {
    navTransitions.showUserInfoScreen()
  }
  
  ...
}

WelcomeScreenViewController.swift

struct WelcomeScreenTransitions {
  let showHome: User? -> Void
  let showCreateAccountScreen: Void -> Void
}

class WelcomeScreenViewController: UIViewController {
  var navTransitions: WelcomeScreenTransitions!
  var webService: WebServiceAPI!
  
  @IBAction func loginAction(_: AnyObject) {
    webService.login(userTextField.text, passwordTextField.text) { (user: User?) in
      navTransitions.showHome(user)
    }
  }
  
  @IBAction func createAccountAction(_: AnyObject) {
    navTransitions.showCreateAccountScreen()
  }
}

Mmmh… In that kind of code:

    vc.navTransitions = WelcomeScreenTransitions(
      showHome: self.pushHomeScreen, // see private func below
      showCreateAccountScreen: self.pushCreateAccountScreen
    )

I don't think we can use [unowned self] in the closure, as self here is the struct Coordinator so as a struct it's a value type and can't be marked unowned (doesn't have any sense for anything non-reference type)
But we can't either [unowned window] as the window isn't even referenced / captured in that closure (as we point the closures to private functions and not providing the implementations inline)

So I'm a bit puzzled here… is there really a reference cycle here (even with value types, though the struct Coordinator contains reference types like window: UIWindow), or is the cycle broken thanks to value types… and if it's not, how to break it as I believe we can't use unowned on a struct?

Will definitely have to try that in an actual playground at some point…

Ok there definitely are issues with retain cycles, and a struct/value type containing reference types doesn't help making things clear on this front.

The right solution might be to make Coordinator a class instead of a struct (which actually makes sense, as we don't really want independent copies all over), and be sure then to use [unowned self] in closures when appropriate.

that's really awesome ! Good job AliSoftware 👽 .

How to do you handle the cas with UITabBarController with severals UIViewController ?

1. create and instance the UITabBarController directly in the appCoordinator.
2. group all the transitions in the UITabBarController

@remirobert good question never had that use case until know. Since that gist using closure I've finally switched back to the delegates version of that Coordinator pattern anyway, which avoids the risk of hidden retain cycles we have with closures everywhere here

@remirobert @AliSoftware any word or example code on using uitabcontroller with coordinator pattern?