Use trait objects (&dyn Fn()
) when you need runtime polymorphism and don't mind the small performance cost of dynamic dispatch.
Use generics (F: Fn()
) for better performance through static dispatch, but at the cost of potential code bloat due to monomorphization.
Use Box<dyn Fn()>
when you need to own the function and have runtime polymorphism, but be aware of the heap allocation overhead.
Feature | Trait Objects (&dyn Fn() ) |
Generics (F: Fn() ) |
Smart Pointer (Box<dyn Fn()> ) |
---|---|---|---|
Type | Trait Object | Generic | Smart Pointer |
Runtime/Compile-time | Runtime | Compile-time | Runtime |
Use Case | When you need runtime polymorphism | When you need better performance and can handle code bloat | When you need to own the function and have runtime polymorphism |
Dispatch | ✅ Static Dispatch | ||
Performance | ✅ Better performance due to static dispatch | ||
Code Bloat | ✅ No code bloat | ✅ No code bloat | |
Ownership | ❌ No ownership | ❌ No ownership | ✅ Ownership |
Heap Allocation | ✅ No heap allocation | ✅ No heap allocation | ❌ Heap allocation overhead |
Flexibility | ❌ Less flexible, requires dyn keyword |
❌ Less flexible, requires Box and dyn keywords |
|
Commonalities | ✅ Provides static dispatch | ||
dyn keyword |
Box and dyn keywords |
||
Differences | ❌ No ownership, no heap allocation | ❌ No ownership, no heap allocation | ✅ Ownership, heap allocation overhead |
✅ Better performance, potential code bloat |