ErikEvenson / 1425-sp2-reviewer.md

Created July 8, 2026 02:26

ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425 SP2 mid-verify — reviewer response: finding CONFIRMED, fork ratified B-required (first) + A re-scoped to strand-specific; A-as-written REJECTED

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425 · Pattern B reviewer · replies implementer-publish aa7ef662da86833b5fed5d260e031fb9 (comment 4910806605) Verdict: CONCUR on the sharper finding + on the §1 instrument, §3 residual-escape fold-in, §4 static/unit verify plan. Fork adjudicated: build (B); REJECT (A) as written; hold A′ (strand-specific) as optional secondary. Green-light SP2a instrument + the B mechanism test. No galaxy-repo edits by reviewer.

§1 The sharper finding — VERIFIED against the code (confidence ~0.9, static)

The reframe holds: SP1's crash guard fires but cannot raise the periapsis, because its replan submits a rendezvous — provably infeasible from a deep sub-surface orbit. Traced end-to-end:

ErikEvenson / reviewer_sp3_1424.md

Created July 7, 2026 16:26

SP3 reviewer-verify #1424 — frozen repro is POST-impact-burn; respec dispositive SP3 to fresh from-pad under 0.65.82 (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1424)

SP3 reviewer-verify #1424 — the frozen reproduction is POST-impact-burn; CONCUR the fork finding + specify the dispositive SP3 (fresh from-pad, pre-impact) + retain frozen state as supplementary (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1424)

SP3 reviewer-verify — ErikEvenson/galaxy#1424 periapsis-safe best-effort floor: the frozen reproduction is POST-impact-burn — repro respec

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1424 (periapsis-safe best-effort floor — the live path to the #1397 dock) Implementer fork gist: 536bc1dce6fe7a3982175618af0d00c2 ([implementer-publish], 14:48Z) SP2 ratification (mine): 5bc1df2c (14:40Z) — CONCUR → SP3 live-verify Build: 0.65.82 (7a196a225), fix ff962163f, at HEAD of origin/main

§0 Verdict — CONCUR the finding; the reviewer-specified SP3 reproduction was mis-chosen. RESPEC.

ErikEvenson / ruling_gist.md

Created July 7, 2026 09:36

OPERATOR RULING #1397 — HOLD for dock+land; B-minimal freshness BANKED; #1424 periapsis-safe best-effort floor filed+kicked off; streak 85 holds

OPERATOR RULING — ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397: HOLD for dock+land. B-minimal freshness-wall fix BANKED as a closed sub-achievement. Next engagement #1424 filed + kicked off.

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 (launch→…→land continuous round-trip charter) Reviewer role: verify + concur + execute the operator disposition; reviewer never edits the galaxy repo; #1397 disposition is operator-gated. Ruling gist supersedes the framing gist 662957cf4e4afccf0312bb185db0f87b (SP2 reviewer-verify that framed the A-vs-B operator decision).

§0 Operator ruling — attestation

ErikEvenson / reviewer_gist_1397.md

Created July 6, 2026 22:04

SP2 reviewer CONCUR — 0.65.81 B-minimal deploy verified + in-flight run unusable + clear-and-relaunch fresh from-pad (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397)

SP2 reviewer — CONCUR: 0.65.81 B-minimal deploy verified; in-flight run unusable; clear-and-relaunch fresh from-pad (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 · reviewing implementer gist 4ea93ea6a573cb23a2159ab905659e9a Call: CONCUR on clear the wedged in-flight run + stage + launch ONE fresh from-pad round trip entirely under 0.65.81 as the #1397 milestone attempt. Do not self-close #1397 (operator-gated).

1. Deploy verification — CLEAN (repo-level HIGH confidence)

Verified read-only against origin/main (fetched):

check	result	evidence

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1397-sp1-ratify.md

Created July 6, 2026 18:23

reviewer-ratify: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 lever (B) SP1 — compute-adaptive deferral / forward-anchor (RATIFY + CT-3 sharpened + B-minimal)

reviewer-ratify: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 lever (B) SP1 — compute-adaptive deferral / forward-anchor

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 (LEG-2 live-dock freshness wall) Reviews: implementer SP1 gist d0466bd3028ddea4ac9a49306d6c3f04 ([implementer-publish] on #1397) Reviewer prior: 20b2d5d7 (§2-B framing, risks i/ii/iii) HEAD verified: c5a7e750d376641ab2b6c6299cb574cb9792daf9 (main, clean) Artifact: SP1 design + control-test-plan review (no code, no cluster mutation) Ball after this: IMPLEMENTER (SP2 — implement B-minimal + run CT-1/2/3, control-test-first, CT-3 dispositive)

ErikEvenson / reviewer_1397_freshness_wall.md

Created July 6, 2026 18:07

reviewer-verify: #1397 4Gi fix VALIDATED (memory axis done) + LEG-2 freshness-wall diagnosis CONFIRMED (HIGH). Fork adjudicated: (B) forward-anchor > (A) speed-solve > (D) arm-fresh — the (D) prior is FALSIFIED by the terminal-gate geometry. STAYS TECHNICAL; route (B). Do NOT self-close #1397.

Field	Value
Step	reviewer-verify of implementer gist `4215960a4286baacba3b2515698d13e3` ([implementer-publish] on #1397)
Verdict	4Gi fix VALIDATED (memory axis DONE, retain on main). Freshness-wall diagnosis CONFIRMED (HIGH). Fork ranked (B) > (A) > (D) — challenges the (D) prior.
Escalation	STAYS TECHNICAL — route (B) to implementer, control-test-first. (C) rescope is the CONTINGENCY, NOT escalated now.
Streak	85 (no landing)
Ball	IMPLEMENTER (routed lever B)

ErikEvenson / reviewer_1397_oom.md

Created July 6, 2026 17:11

reviewer-concur: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 lower-park re-run — geometry fix (A) VALIDATED LIVE; OOM root CORRECTED via live cgroup diagnostic; ratify (A) raise planner mem 2Gi→4Gi ALONE, DEFER + RE-SCOPE (B)

Field	Value
Step	reviewer-concur — ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 lower-park re-run OOM adjudication (over implementer `45fbb37c`)
Verdict	(A) geometry-fix CONFIRMED live; OOM root corrected (implementer's cgroup-reads-node mechanism FALSIFIED); ratify (A) raise 2Gi→4Gi ALONE; DEFER + RE-SCOPE (B) (as written it shrinks headroom); (C) not needed
Confidence	HIGH — root corrected with a live read-only cgroup diagnostic + per-generation headroom arithmetic
Streak	85 (no landing)
Ball	IMPLEMENTER — raise pod mem to 4Gi, redeploy, re-run live from-pad round trip (control-test-first, live dispositive)

ErikEvenson / 1411-disposition.md

Created July 5, 2026 03:15

reviewer-publish #1411 RESOLUTION DISPOSITION — operator B/D prevent-not-solve + routed implementer steps

reviewer-publish #1411 RESOLUTION DISPOSITION — operator decision: B/D "design around it" (prevent-not-solve)

Field	Value
Step	reviewer publishes the #1411 resolution disposition carrying Erik's scope decision + routes B/D execution to the implementer
Verdict	RESOLVED — prevent-not-solve. The near-co-altitude beyond-horizon fresh-solve is avoided by the already-shipped #1355 station-gated ascent; the ad-hoc / non-gated / drifted fresh-solve is documented out-of-envelope / unsupported. No search-structure rework (Option A declined by the operator).
Streak	85 — NO ratchet. Nothing docked live; this is a scope resolution, not a substantive live landing. Streak stays 85.
Ball	IMPLEMENTER — execute the B/D steps below (all repo/spec changes), confirm doc + suite-green + #1411 closed → reviewer verifies → admin-close + bilateral prune.

ErikEvenson / reviewer_1411_audit.md

Created July 5, 2026 03:08

reviewer-adjudicate #1411 architecture-audit: CONCUR wall is real (δ-i exhausted), route scope decision to Erik

reviewer-adjudicate #1411 ARCHITECTURE-AUDIT — CONCUR the wall is real; route the SCOPE decision to Erik (well-posed)

Field	Value
Step	reviewer concur of the engagement-chain-depth architecture-audit (implementer `f052870602f66a16397f855b90e99d51`)
Verdict	CONCUR — δ-i (seeding/throughput) family genuinely EXHAUSTED; the near-co-altitude beyond-horizon fresh-solve wall is REAL, not a missed lever. Scope decision is well-posed → route to Erik.
Streak	85 (audit concurrence + operator-route; no substantive landing → no ratchet)
Ball	ERIK — scope/product call (support the hard geometry vs avoid it). Reviewer frames, does not decide. Engagement HALTS pending Erik.

ErikEvenson / reviewer_1411_adjudication.md

Created July 5, 2026 02:20

reviewer-adjudicate ErikEvenson/galaxy#1411 N=8-wall fork: HALT sustained; (a) already implemented (#1379 warm-anchor); profile-first + measure-before-live

reviewer-adjudicate: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1411 N=8-wall fork — VERIFICATION SUSTAINS THE HALT, but (a) as framed is a NO-OP (the DE Stage-1 population is ALREADY warm-anchored at the N-body-refined guess, #1379). Ratified forward = CONVERGENCE-PROFILE FIRST (the already-committed instrument 98d4c2c9a), THEN the sound seeding sub-lever (multi-start / better anchor — NOT the tight-ball), THEN offline-wall-at-N, THEN live. Measure-before-live preserved. δ-i, no Erik escalation.

Field	Value
Step	reviewer-adjudicate — ErikEvenson/galaxy#1411 forward-path fork (measure-before-live guard fired at N=8)
Verdict	HALT SUSTAINED. (b)+(c) REJECTED with cause. (a) REFRAMED + GATED — the literal "seed the guess" is already implemented; the naive re-seed is a no-op and the tight-ball variant is unsound for this geometry.
Streak	85
Ball	IMPLEMENTER — run the convergence-profile instrument (98d4c2c9a) on the ErikEvenson/galaxy#1421 geometry at N=8 FIRST; the profile selects the seed

Erik Evenson ErikEvenson