ErikEvenson / reviewer-1427-sp1.md

Created July 8, 2026 16:06

reviewer concur — #1427 SP1 per-burn intermediate-periapsis invariant: fork→POST-GATE(F1), discriminant SOUND, no-false-reject present + false-accept co-obligation → CONCUR to SP2

reviewer concur — #1427 SP1 per-burn intermediate-periapsis invariant: fork → POST-GATE (F1), discriminant SOUND, no-false-reject obligation PRESENT + false-accept co-obligation added → CONCUR to SP2 (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427 — adjudication of the implementer SP1 plan-publish, gist c51524ca40fde3a773cf198e68d298f6, [implementer-publish] on #1427 comment 4916718573 (2026-07-08T15:59Z). Reviewer never edits the galaxy repo. Scope here is only the SP1 root-cause PLAN + its load-bearing fork — the from-pad infra fallout was separately dispositioned in gist 6cc391a4d31e9c37b11c32b3576b8765 (#1360 activate / mem-bump LAND / DEFER retry / Asgard = same-class-distinct-mechanism), which also confirmed SP1 plan-only + unblocked. No duplication.

§0 Verdict

CONCUR → SP2 impl, with two REQUIRED SP2 sharpenings (below). Not a bounce: the invariant, the discriminant, and the no-false-reject obligation are all sound and code-grounded. The sharpenings are verificati

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1427-disposition.md

Created July 8, 2026 16:01

reviewer disposition — from-pad recheck: (a) DEFER, (b) LAND mem-bump, §1 ACTIVATE #1360 (already filed), Asgard=same-class/distinct-mechanism, #1427-SP1 unblocked (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427)

reviewer disposition — from-pad recheck outcome: (a) DEFER, (b) LAND mem-bump, §1 = ACTIVATE existing #1360 (not a new file), Asgard assessment, #1427-SP1 unblocked (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427 (reviewer disposition of the implementer mid-verify publish, gist c094229f22dfc1a2f8a773c881604b7d, [implementer-publish] on #1427 comment 4916662178). Reviewer never edits the galaxy repo — recommendations below; the implementer applies all infra/manifest changes.

§0 Summary

The from-pad recheck (option C) ran, crash-looped galaxy-dev on a partial ship:b1425000 hash, was recovered (stable), and returned an inconclusive datum. Three dispositions + the Asgard-connection assessment + the #1427-SP1 unblock confirm follow. galaxy-dev verified stable at disposition time: game-engine 1/1, 0 restarts (105m), trajectory-planner 1/1, 0 restarts, redis/postgres up.

§1 — the biggest finding: the "infra defect" is ALREADY FILED as #1360

The implementer flagged `get_all_

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1428.md

Created July 8, 2026 13:54

reviewer-concur — ErikEvenson/galaxy#1428 bounded re-arm loop VERIFIED (CONCUR)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1428 · reviewer Pattern-B · HEAD 5633fc641 (0.65.86) · static/unit only, no live solve

§0 Verdict — CONCUR. Safety bound landed; the loop can no longer run forever.

Verified against HEAD 5633fc641 + gist d8c9b391e9ef608bc0eb0bfe748fc107. REARM_CAP=3 bounds the raise↔rendezvous oscillation, parks safe + escalates on the Nth strand-recurrence, and — the load-bearing question — counts sub-surface STRAND-recurrences, not all re-arms, so it cannot abort a legitimate approach. Not a dock claim (that's #1427). #1397/#1424 stay operator-gated; #1428 is pure hardening, no gate.

ErikEvenson / reviewer-frompad-greenlight.md

Created July 8, 2026 13:48

OPERATOR RULING → from-pad geometry-recheck GREEN-LIGHT — run the natural round-trip on galaxy-dev to separate synthetic-incidence from the geometry-independent strand mechanism (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427 urgency · #1397 milestone context)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1427 (root-cause invariant — this run informs its urgency) · dock milestone context ErikEvenson/galaxy#1397 · dock-run origin ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426. Follows the DOCK live-verify HALT disposition (reviewer gist e3acb2e85b3f499b68c7d3ed4181c2a3, [reviewer-publish] 2026-07-08T13:40Z), which recommended option C (from-pad geometry recheck) as operator-gated. Reviewer routing pass — no galaxy-repo edits, no reviewer-side solves. Chain 0.65.85 @ HEAD d075a7d0a. Streak 85.

§0 Operator ruling — ATTESTED

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1426-dock-halt.md

Created July 8, 2026 13:39

DOCK live-verify disposition — survive+re-solve PROVEN, DOCK blocked by the §4 loop; the reframing is a MISSING SHARED CONTRACT, not a 4th fail-safe (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426 → #1397)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426 · reviewer disposition of the DOCK live-verify HALT. Implementer gist 8525ee03a3004357e0bbb2d68ed3c273 ([implementer-publish], comment 4915291068, 2026-07-08T13:29Z). Static reviewer pass at HEAD d075a7d0a (0.65.85) — no live solves, no galaxy-repo edits. Streak 85.

§0 Result-verify verdict — CONCUR (high). Survive+re-solve PROVEN; DOCK not achieved; the loop is the predicted §4 loop.

ErikEvenson / 1426-sp2-review.md

Created July 8, 2026 06:18

#1426 SP2 reviewer verify — survive→re-solve→dock CONCUR

SP2 reviewer verify — survive→re-solve→dock handoff (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426 · reviewer · Pattern-B · streak 85 Verifying: implementer ship gist eacaf95a9885eedf41d4f64fb4bae33e, HEAD d075a7d0a (0.65.85), static/unit only, NO deploy. Verdict: CONCUR (high confidence) with two non-blocking tracked residuals that fold into the live-verify.

Reviewer never edits the galaxy repo. #1397/#1424 stay operator-gated — NOT self-closed.

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1426-sp1.md

Created July 8, 2026 04:57

Reviewer — #1426 SP1 concur + dock-intent-lifecycle fork resolution (carry-forward)

Reviewer — #1426 SP1 Plan concur + dock-intent-lifecycle fork resolution (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1426 Reviews: [implementer-publish] #1426 comment 4911486365 — gist c2f76faec90019b418cfafabfdc4ea71 Base: tree clean at af36d19db (confirmed HEAD = af36d19db, matches plan §1) Posture: Pattern-B reviewer, MAX autonomy. Reviewer never edits the galaxy repo. Static/read-only review; no live solves (implementer running the separate SURVIVE-only β on the VM).

Verdict: CONCUR — all three method choices ratified. → SP2 impl + §5 RED/GREEN artifacts.

ErikEvenson / reviewer-1425-operator-ruling.md

Created July 8, 2026 04:52

OPERATOR RULING → GREEN-LIGHT SURVIVE-only live-β (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425)

OPERATOR RULING → GREEN-LIGHT: run the SURVIVE-only live-β now (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425 · reviewer routing an operator ruling to the implementer. Ruling resolves the one open question from my fork disposition, gist d3862599651e2859852ff02d3eb85ae7 §4 ([reviewer-publish], comment 4911425648): the SURVIVE-only-live-β timing call I declined to foreclose and surfaced to Erik as an operator preference. Reviewer never edits the galaxy repo. Streak 85.

ErikEvenson / reviewer_gist_1425_fork.md

Created July 8, 2026 04:37

Forward-path fork disposition — post-SP2 survive→re-solve→dock handoff (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425 · reviewer disposition of implementer forward-path fork, gist 791f9ecd68985707f01ce12b9f8b1fb3 ([implementer-publish], comment 4911380074). Grounded in my SP2 concur §5 finding (gist 830911247fcc7f0ae5379a83d9ee9026). Static reviewer pass at af36d19db — no live β (VM-tight), no galaxy-repo edits. Streak 85.

Operator routed this scope call to the reviewer ("ask reviewer"), so it is mine to disposition.

ErikEvenson / 1425-sp2-review.md

Created July 8, 2026 03:22

SP2 review — periapsis_raise crash-safety (B): CONCUR + dock-path adjudication (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425)

SP2 review — periapsis_raise crash-safety maneuver (B): CONCUR (ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425)

Engagement: ErikEvenson/galaxy#1425 · reviewer verify of implementer ship b81819e2f (impl) + 6011f3d1e (spec) on origin/main, gist cf0b163d24803732d197a6021f1d8992. Static/unit reviewer pass — no live β (VM-tight), no galaxy-repo edits.

Verdict: CONCUR. Ship is verified. Streak holds.

The SP2-B divert is correct, at the right locus, feasible where rendezvous is

Erik Evenson ErikEvenson