Fix notifications for auto skipped videos

claude-history.md

Right now, what is happening is that I have two features that are not working well together:

1. Auto skip configuration (e.g., to skip short videos)
2. Notification So if I'm skipping automatically something, of course I don't want to be notified by that because I'm skipping it completely. We should only notify after the skip process has run. Analyze both codes and ask questions to me if you have any doubts.

⏺ I'll analyze both the auto skip configuration and notification features to understand how they interact and why notifications are being sent for skipped content. Let me first explore the codebase to find these implementations.

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☐ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☐ Find notification system implementation ☐ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☐ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☐ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☐ Find notification system implementation ☐ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☐ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

⏺ Search(pattern: "skip.*config|auto.*skip|skip.*short") ⎿  Found 2 files (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Search(pattern: "notification|notify") ⎿  Found 20 files (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Let me examine the auto skip configuration first:

⏺ Read(web/app/home/Settings.js) ⎿  Read 138 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Read(web/app/home/SettingsModal.js) ⎿  Read 130 lines (ctrl+r to expand) ⎿  web/CLAUDE.md

⏺ Now let me examine the notification service to understand how notifications are triggered:

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☐ Find notification system implementation ☐ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☐ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

⏺ Read(web/app/notifications/notificationService.js) ⎿  Read 151 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Read(web/app/notifications/notificationsMethods.js) ⎿  Read 96 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Now let me find where the auto-skip logic is implemented and where notifications are created:

⏺ Search(pattern: "autoSkipShorts|auto.*skip", output_mode: "content") ⎿  Found 14 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Search(pattern: "createNewVideoNotification|createBatchVideoNotifications", output_mode: "content") ⎿  Found 13 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Perfect! Now I can see the key issue. Let me examine the videoService.js file to understand how the auto-skip and notifications interact:

⏺ Read(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Read 30 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Read(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Read 40 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Now I can see the issue! Let me analyze the full logic by reading a broader section:

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☒ Find notification system implementation ☐ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☐ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

⏺ Read(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Read 60 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Perfect! Now I have a complete understanding of the issue. Let me analyze what's happening:

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☒ Find notification system implementation ☒ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☐ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

⏺ Analysis Complete

I've found the issue! Here's what's happening:

Current Flow:

1. Auto-skip logic (videoService.js:88-93): When a video is detected as a short AND autoSkipShorts is enabled, it sets the status to SKIPPED
2. Notification logic (videoService.js:108-109): All new videos (including auto-skipped ones) are added to newVideosForEmail
3. Email/Notification sending (videoService.js:254-295): All videos in newVideosForEmail get notifications sent, regardless of their skip status

The Problem:

The auto-skip filtering happens before adding to the notification queue, but the video is still added to newVideosForEmail regardless of whether it was auto-skipped. This means skipped videos still trigger notifications.

Questions for you:

1. Notification scope: Should we prevent notifications for ALL auto-skipped videos, or only for specific types (like shorts)?
2. Existing skipped videos: Should we also prevent notifications for videos that were manually skipped by users, or only auto-skipped ones?
3. Batching impact: When we filter out skipped videos, should we still send batch notifications for the remaining videos, or does this change how you want batching to work?

The fix would be to filter newVideosForEmail to exclude videos with status === VideoStatus.SKIPPED before the notification logic runs around line 254.

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Find auto skip configuration implementation
☒ Find notification system implementation ☒ Analyze interaction between skip and notification features ☒ Identify where notifications should be prevented for skipped content

Ok, I will reply one by one:

1. Yes for all skipped videos.
2. Doesn't make sense to be possible to prevent a notification for a video that is skipped because the video is already there, so it was already notified. Only for all to skip it once.
3. It doesn't change anything about the batching notification system for the other videos.

⏺ Perfect! Your answers clarify everything. Let me implement the fix to prevent notifications for all auto-skipped videos.

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☐ Filter out skipped videos from notification queue
☐ Test the fix and verify notifications work correctly

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☐ Filter out skipped videos from notification queue
☐ Test the fix and verify notifications work correctly

⏺ The fix is simple: filter out skipped videos from the notification queue before sending notifications. I need to add a filter right before the notification logic starts.

⏺ Read(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Read 15 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ I need to see what VideoStatus values are available first:

⏺ Search(pattern: "VideoStatus|SKIPPED", output_mode: "content") ⎿  Found 71 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Perfect! I can see that VideoStatus.SKIPPED is available. Now let me implement the fix:

⏺ Update(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Updated web/app/videos/videoService.js with 7 additions and 2 removals
225 { upsert: true } 226 ); 227
228 + // Filter out skipped videos from notification queue 229 + const videosToNotify = newVideosForEmail.filter( 230 + (video) => video.status !== VideoStatus.SKIPPED 231 + ); 232 +
233 // Send email notifications for new videos 234 console.log( 235 - [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Email notification flow starting - ${newVideosForEmail.length} new videos found - found235 + [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Email notification flow starting - ${newVideosForEmail.length} new videos found, ${videosToNotify.length} will be notified (${newVideosForEmail.length - videosToNotify.length} auto-skipped) + found, ${videosToNotify.length} will be notified (${newVideosForEmail.length - videosToNotify.length} auto-skipped) 236 ); 237
238 - if (newVideosForEmail.length > 0) { 238 + if (videosToNotify.length > 0) { 239 try { 240 console.log( 241 [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Fetching user data for email notifications - userId: ${userId}

⏺ Now I need to update all the references to newVideosForEmail in the notification logic to use videosToNotify instead:

⏺ Update(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Updated web/app/videos/videoService.js with 7 additions and 7 removals
261 [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Email conditions met - proceeding with email notification 262 ); 263
264 - if (newVideosForEmail.length === 1) { 264 + if (videosToNotify.length === 1) { 265 console.log( 266 - [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Sending individual video notification for: "${newVideosForEmail[0].title}" - "${newVideosForEmail[0].title}"266 + [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Sending individual video notification for: "${videosToNotify[0].title}" + "${videosToNotify[0].title}" 267 ); 268
269 // Send individual video notification 270 await EmailService.sendNewVideoNotification({ 271 userEmail, 272 - video: newVideosForEmail[0], 272 + video: videosToNotify[0], 273 channel, 274 }); 275
276 // Create notification in database 277 await NotificationService.createNewVideoNotification({ 278 userId, 279 - video: newVideosForEmail[0], 279 + video: videosToNotify[0], 280 channel, 281 }); 282 } else { 283 console.log( 284 - [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Sending batch notification for ${newVideosForEmail.length} videos 284 + [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Sending batch notification for ${videosToNotify.length} videos 285 ); 286
287 // Send batch notification for multiple videos 288 await EmailService.sendBatchVideoNotification({ 289 userEmail, 290 - videos: newVideosForEmail, 290 + videos: videosToNotify, 291 channel, 292 }); 293
294 // Create notifications in database 295 await NotificationService.createBatchVideoNotifications({ 296 userId, 297 - videos: newVideosForEmail, 297 + videos: videosToNotify, 298 channel, 299 }); 300 }

⏺ I need to update the final log message as well:

⏺ Update(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Updated web/app/videos/videoService.js with 1 addition and 1 removal
300 } 301
302 console.log( 303 - [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Email notification sent successfully for ${newVideosForEmail.length} new videos to ${userEmail} - videos to ${userEmail}303 + [VideoService.syncChannelVideos][${channel.title}] Email notification sent successfully for ${videosToNotify.length} new videos to ${userEmail} + videos to ${userEmail} 304 ); 305 } else if (!userEmail) { 306 console.log(

⏺ Perfect! Now let me run the quality checks to make sure the code is correct:

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Filter out skipped videos from notification queue
☐ Test the fix and verify notifications work correctly

⏺ Bash(meteor npm run quave-check) ⎿  > quave-check
> cd web && npm run quave-check … +75 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Great! The code passes all linting and formatting checks. Now let me verify the fix by reviewing the updated code:

⏺ Read(web/app/videos/videoService.js) ⎿  Read 20 lines (ctrl+r to expand)

⏺ Update Todos ⎿  ☒ Filter out skipped videos from notification queue
☒ Test the fix and verify notifications work correctly

⏺ ✅ Fix Implemented Successfully

The issue has been resolved! Here's what I changed in videoService.js:228-303:

The Fix:

1. Added filtering logic before the notification flow to exclude auto-skipped videos: const videosToNotify = newVideosForEmail.filter( (video) => video.status !== VideoStatus.SKIPPED );
2. Updated all notification references to use videosToNotify instead of newVideosForEmail
3. Enhanced logging to show how many videos were auto-skipped vs. will be notified

How it works now:

• Auto-skip still happens during video insertion (line 90-93)
• Videos with status: SKIPPED are filtered out before notifications
• Only non-skipped videos trigger email/push notifications
• Batching logic remains unchanged for the remaining videos
• Clear logging shows the filtering in action

The fix ensures that when auto-skip is enabled for shorts (or any video), users won't receive notifications for content they've configured to skip automatically.