George Polya (1887-1985) was a Hungarian mathematician and educator who revolutionized our understanding of problem-solving and teaching. While he made significant contributions to mathematics, his most enduring legacy is his insights into how people learn and solve problems. His 1945 book "How to Solve It" has influenced educators across numerous fields, extending far beyond mathematics.
Polya's approach centered on three key principles. First, he championed active learning, believing students learn best by discovering solutions themselves rather than being told answers. Second, he emphasized heuristic thinking - the art of guided discovery and learning from experience, viewing problem-solving as a skill that can be developed through practice. Third, he developed sophisticated questioning techniques that guide students toward solutions while encouraging independent thinking.
-
Understand the Problem
- Clearly identify what you're being asked to do
- Gather all available information
- Identify constraints and limitations
- Restate the problem in your own words
- Create visual representations where helpful
- Verify you have sufficient information
-
Devise a Plan
- Search for patterns
- Draw on similar problems you've solved
- Break down complex problems into manageable parts
- Consider working backward from the goal
- Look for ways to simplify the problem
- List possible strategies
- Identify available tools and resources
-
Carry Out the Plan
- Execute your strategy systematically
- Verify each step
- Document your attempts
- Be prepared to start over with a new approach if needed
- Maintain organized records of your process
-
Look Back and Reflect
- Evaluate the reasonableness of your solution
- Verify your results
- Consider alternative approaches
- Extract lessons learned
- Consider broader applications
- Identify potential improvements for future attempts
- Analogy: Find similar problems and patterns, drawing on past experience.
- Decomposition: Break complex problems into smaller, manageable parts.
- Generalization and Specialization: Identify broad principles while testing specific cases.
- Working Backwards: Start from the desired outcome and trace steps backward.
- Auxiliary Elements: Add helpful constructions, diagrams, notation, or intermediate goals.
The book emphasizes several crucial components for effective problem-solving:
- Strategic Questioning: Develop self-dialogue and guide discovery through thoughtful questions
- Positive Mindset: Maintain persistence, embrace learning from failures, and cultivate curiosity
- Effective Teaching: Guide rather than instruct, encourage independence, and build confidence
- Documentation: Keep clear records of thoughts, attempts, and processes
Analogy (p. 39): Look for similar problems you've solved before or related situations with similar structure.
Auxiliary elements (p. 47): Introduce helpful additions - new lines, points, notations, variables, or intermediate goals.
Auxiliary problem (p. 51): Solve a related or modified version of the problem that might provide insight.
Bolzano (p. 56): References the mathematician's contributions to problem-solving.
Bright idea (p. 56): Discusses the role of insight and inspiration in problem-solving.
Can you check the result? (p. 58): Verify the solution through substitution, special cases, or alternative methods.
Can you derive the result differently? (p. 59): Seek alternative solutions or proofs to verify and deepen understanding.
Can you use the result? (p. 62): Consider how the solution or method might apply elsewhere or generalize.
Carrying out (p. 65): Execute your plan systematically, verifying each step.
Condition (p. 68): Examine the conditions/constraints of the problem carefully.
Contradictory (p. 69): Addresses handling contradictory conditions or assumptions.
Corollary (p. 69): Derive additional results that follow directly from your solution.
Could you derive something useful from the data? (p. 69): Extract intermediate results or relationships from given information.
Could you restate the problem? (p. 71): Reformulate the problem in different terms or from a different perspective.
Decomposing and recombining (p. 71): Break the problem apart and reassemble pieces in new ways.
Definition (p. 79): Return to precise definitions of key terms in the problem.
Descartes (p. 85): References Descartes' approach to problem-solving methodology.
Determination, hope, success (p. 85): Maintain persistence and positive mindset throughout problem-solving.
Diagnosis (p. 87): Analyze what's working and what isn't in your approach.
Did you use all the data? (p. 87): Check whether you've incorporated all given information.
Do you know a related problem? (p. 89): Search your experience for problems with similar features.
Draw a figure! (p. 90): Create visual representations to clarify relationships.
Examine your guess (p. 90): Test and analyze conjectures systematically.
Figures (p. 94): Use diagrams, sketches, and visual aids.
Generalization (p. 98): Extend the problem to broader cases to reveal patterns.
Have you seen it before? (p. 99): Recall if you've encountered this problem or similar ones.
Here is a problem related to yours and solved before (p. 100): Draw on solutions to analogous problems.
Heuristic (p. 101): Discusses the nature of heuristic reasoning itself.
Heuristic reasoning (p. 102): Use plausible reasoning and guided discovery.
If you cannot solve the proposed problem (p. 102): Try a simpler or related problem first.
Induction and mathematical induction (p. 103): Use inductive reasoning and formal proof techniques.
Inventor's paradox (p. 109): Sometimes a more general problem is easier to solve than a specific one.
Is it possible to satisfy the condition? (p. 109): Check whether the constraints can be met.
Leibniz (p. 110): References Leibniz's contributions to problem-solving methodology.
Lemma (p. 110): Prove intermediate results that help solve the main problem.
Look at the unknown (p. 111): Focus on what you're trying to find and its properties.
Modern heuristic (p. 116): Discusses contemporary approaches to heuristic problem-solving.
Notation (p. 120): Introduce clear, systematic notation to organize information.
Pappus (p. 125): If the solution requires finding a point or element, try to determine its position/properties first.
Pedantry and mastery (p. 131): Discusses the balance between rigor and insight.
Practical problems (p. 132): Applying heuristics to real-world situations.
Problems to find, problems to prove (p. 136): Recognize whether you're seeking to construct/find something or to prove a statement.
Progress and achievement (p. 138): Recognizing and building on partial progress.
Puzzles (p. 141): The role of recreational problems in developing problem-solving skills.
Reductio ad absurdum and indirect proof (p. 142): Assume the opposite and derive a contradiction.
Redundant (p. 150): Identifying and handling redundant conditions or information.
Routine problem (p. 150): Recognize standard problem types and apply known methods.
Rules of discovery (p. 150): Systematic approaches to finding solutions.
Rules of style (p. 151): Principles for clear mathematical presentation.
Rules of teaching (p. 151): Pedagogical approaches to problem-solving instruction.
Separate the various parts of the condition (p. 151): Break down complex conditions into individual components.
Setting up equations (p. 152): Translate problem relationships into mathematical equations.
Signs of progress (p. 155): Recognize indicators that you're moving toward a solution.
Specialization (p. 165): Test the problem with specific cases or simpler instances.
Subconscious work (p. 171): Allow time for ideas to incubate; insights often emerge after stepping away.
Symmetry (p. 173): Look for and exploit symmetrical relationships in the problem.
Terms, old and new (p. 173): Distinguish between familiar and unfamiliar concepts.
Test by dimension (p. 175): Check if units/dimensions are consistent in your solution.
The future mathematician (p. 178): Developing problem-solving skills over time.
The intelligent problem-solver (p. 179): Characteristics of effective problem-solvers.
The intelligent reader (p. 179): Approaching problems as an active, engaged learner.
The traditional mathematics professor (p. 180): Common teaching approaches and their limitations.
Variation of the problem (p. 181): Modify the problem slightly to gain new perspectives.
What is the unknown? (p. 185): Clearly identify what you're trying to find.
Why proofs? (p. 186): The role and value of mathematical proof.
Wisdom of proverbs (p. 191): Traditional wisdom applied to problem-solving.
Working backwards (p. 194): Start from the desired result and trace steps backward to the given information.