gift_idea.html

<li> 
  <a class='prodImage' href='#' target='_blank'> 
    <img alt='' src='/images/wg_noProdImage.png'> 
  </a> 
  <a class='prodTitle' href='#'> 
    From here, i can just recommend whatever I want.
  </a> 
  <a class='rate_button' href="javascript:">Select</a> 
  <input id='gi_4cd9dafc404aaa17ca000062_selected' name='gi[4cd9dafc404aaa17ca000062][selected]' type='hidden' value='false'> 
  <br class='clear'> 
  <textarea class='addGiftNotes' id='gi_4cd9dafc404aaa17ca000062_comments' name='gi[4cd9dafc404aaa17ca000062][comments]'>Add additional gift notes here (optional)</textarea> 
</li>

Change the Select from an input type=image to an anchor, so it doesn't try and submit the form, and to prevent it from sending fields I don't need.

Also, I'm going to make that select button set that hidden field value to true/false, based on whether it's clicked or not.