Reviewer Validator Disagreement Trace

Reviewer Validator Disagreement Trace

{
  "trace_id": "rvd-001",
  "trace_type": "reviewer_validator_disagreement",
  "submission_class": "buy_side_alpha",
  "submission_summary": {
    "asset_class_band": "us_large_cap_equity",
    "signal_family": "positioning_drift",
    "horizon_band": "1_to_3_months",
    "conviction_band": "medium",
    "sanitization_state": "fully_redacted_synthetic_composite"
  },
  "validator_judgment": {
    "judgment_id": "v_auto",
    "judgment_type": "automated_rule_engine",
    "verdict": "reject",
    "verdict_basis": "near_duplicate_textual_similarity_above_threshold",
    "confidence_band": "high",
    "rule_triggered": "dedup_against_recent_submissions",
    "similarity_band": "above_dedup_floor",
    "features_observed": [
      "submission_text_embedding",
      "tag_overlap",
      "asset_class_overlap"
    ]
  },
  "reviewer_judgment": {
    "judgment_id": "r_human_anon",
    "judgment_type": "qualitative_review",
    "verdict": "accept_with_revision",
    "verdict_basis": "novel_qualitative_context_not_captured_by_text_similarity",
    "confidence_band": "medium",
    "noted_dimensions": [
      "different_underlying_driver",
      "different_position_lifecycle_stage",
      "different_counterparty_archetype_band"
    ]
  },
  "disagreement_profile": {
    "axis": "novelty_assessment",
    "direction": "validator_stricter_than_reviewer",
    "neither_party_malicious": true,
    "root_cause_band": "feature_coverage_gap",
    "root_cause_detail": "validator_uses_textual_similarity_only_reviewer_uses_driver_and_lifecycle_taxonomy"
  },
  "override_basis": {
    "override_type": "qualitative_override_of_automated_rule",
    "override_authority": "secondary_review_panel",
    "evidence_class": "taxonomy_dimensions_outside_validator_feature_set",
    "rationale_summary": "submission_shares_surface_text_with_prior_entries_but_differs_on_driver_and_lifecycle_dimensions_that_validator_does_not_observe",
    "qualitative_evidence_kept_privacy_safe": true,
    "calibration_artifact_attached": true
  },
  "corrected_route": {
    "prior_route": "auto_reject_queue",
    "final_route": "secondary_qualitative_review_then_scoring",
    "reroute_reason": "validator_high_confidence_reject_overturned_on_dimensions_outside_validator_feature_set",
    "downstream_action": "submission_advanced_to_scoring_with_revision_flag",
    "validator_feedback_loop": "feature_gap_logged_for_next_validator_training_window"
  },
  "calibration_label": {
    "label": "validator_false_positive_reviewer_correct",
    "label_scope": "this_trace_only",
    "label_use": "training_signal_for_validator_recalibration",
    "confidence_in_label_band": "medium_high"
  },
  "privacy_controls": {
    "contains_names": false,
    "contains_employers": false,
    "contains_counterparties": false,
    "contains_exact_dates": false,
    "contains_exact_sizes": false,
    "contains_verbatim_quotes": false,
    "contains_private_urls": false,
    "contains_uniquely_identifying_combinations": false
  },
  "schema_version": "rvd_trace_v1",
  "publication_intent": "public_agent_readable_disagreement_trace"
}