This file describes a proposal for a new design of "links" support for OpenAPI v4 (Moonwalk)
There are three key problems with the OpenAPI v3 support for links that this proposal hopes to address:
There are some occasions where a response header or body parameter contains a complete URL, e.g. the "Location" header returned in a 201 response from POST, or the "nextLink" property in the response of a pageable OData list operation. OpenAPI 3 links do not support this scenario.
OpenAPI 3 links cannot specify a field within the request body as the target of a link -- only individual parameters or the entire request body.
OpenAPI 3 only defines "forward" links -- from source to target. Links are defined in the 'response' object and specify how data in the response maps to parameters in a subsequent request. There is no provision for a parameter to point back to a prior operation as the source of data for the parameter.
While it is possible to specify all links in a "forward" fashion, this is cumbersome since data from a single
operation could be the source for many subsequent operations. For example, the "id" returned in a POST response
could supply the value for the "id" path parameter of a GET, PATCH, and DELETE for the same resource and for
any child resources. If the path parameter could "point back" to the post response, this could be specified just
once, in a parameter defined in components.parameters, which would be far more concise.
The Link Object will be extended to support links from fields that contain URLs and links to specific request body properties.
To support "backward links", a links field will be added to the Operation Object to specify operations
that can link to this operation, and two new fields will be added to the Link Object
to specify the source operationId or source operationRef.
The Link Object of OpenAPI v3 will be modfied/extended as follows:
- A new
urlfield will be added - The
requestBodyfield will be redefined to support links to fields within the request body - New fields
sourceIdandsourceRefwill be added to identify the source operation
A url field will be added to the Link Object.
| Field Name | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| url | Any | {expression} | A constant or an expression to be evaluated and passed to the linked operation. The value should be a URL for the linked operation. Applications may extract values for path or query parameters present in this URL to use as values for these parameters in the linked operation. |
A requestBody field of the Link Object will be redefined as follows.
| Field Name | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| requestBody | Map[string, Any | {expression}] |
A map representing values to pass to an operation, as specified with operationId or identified via operationRef, for use in the request body. The key is the JSON path of a request body property in the linked operation, and the value can be a constant or an expression to be evaluated and passed to the linked operation. |
Note that this new structure is a generalization of the requestBody field in OpenAPI v3, since "/" can be used to specify the entire request body of the linked operation.
Two new fields, sourceId and sourceRef will be added to the Link Object to identify the operation that is the
source of information for a parameter or request body.
| Field Name | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| sourceRef | string |
A relative or absolute URI reference to an OAS operation. This field is mutually exclusive of the sourceId field, and MUST point to an Operation Object. Relative operationRef values MAY be used to locate an existing Operation Object in the OpenAPI definition. |
| sourceId | string |
The name of an existing, resolvable OAS operation, as defined with a unique operationId. This field is mutually exclusive of the sourceRef field. |
The sourceRef and sourceId fields identify the operation that is the source of the linked data.
A Link Object may contain both a sourceRef or sourceId AND an operationRef or operationId, which allows the
same Link Object to be referenced from both a Response Object and from Parameter or Request Body Objects.
A links property will be added to the Operation Object with the following definition.
| Field Name | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| links | Map[string, Link Object | Reference Object] |
A map of operations links that can be the source of values for this operation's parameters and/or request body properties. The key of the map is a short name for the link, following the naming constraints of the names for Component Objects. |
The new links design is not compatible with the OpenAPI v3 links structure but it is expected that tooling could translate an OpenAPI v3 definition into OpenAPI v4 with little (ideally no) loss of information.
paths:
/users:
post:
responses:
'201':
description: Created
headers:
Location:
description: The URL of the User that was created
type: string
content:
application/json:
schema:
$ref: '#/components/schemas/User'
links:
location:
operationId: getUser
# The URL in the location header contains the value for id path parameter
url: $response.header.location
/users/{id}:
get:
operationId: getUser
parameters:
- name: id
in: path
required: true
schema:
type: stringpaths:
/users:
get:
operationId: listUsers
responses:
'200':
description: Success
content:
application/json:
schema:
type: object
properties:
value:
type: array
items:
$ref: '#/components/schemas/User'
nextLink:
description: A URL to retrieve the next page of users
type: string
links:
nextLink:
operationId: listUsers
# The URL in the location header contains the value for id path parameter
url: $response.body#/nextLink
The follow example is a simplification of the real-world "ConfigurationStores_RegenerateKey" operation of the Azure App Configuration resource-manager service.
paths:
/listKeys:
post:
description: Lists the access keys for the service.
operationId: ListKeys
responses:
'200':
description: Success
content:
application/json:
schema:
description: The result of a request to list API keys.
type: object
properties:
value:
type: array
items:
description: An API key used for authenticating with the service.
type: object
properties:
id:
description: The key ID.
type: string
name:
description: A name for the key describing its usage.
type: string
links:
keyId:
operationId: RegenerateKey
# The id field of the first key can be set as id property of the request body of RegenerateKey
requestBody:
'/id': '$.response/body#value[0].id'
/regenerateKey:
post:
description: Regenerates an access key for the service.
operationId: RegenerateKey
requestBody:
content:
application/json:
schema:
description: The parameters used to regenerate an API key.
type: object
properties:
id:
description: The id of the key to regenerate.
type: string
description: The parameters for regenerating an access key.
required: true
responses:
'200':
description: Success
content:
application/json:
schema:
$ref: '#/components/schemas/ApiKey' Rather than add a links field to the operation, we could add links to individual parameters and the response body,
but this seems unnecessary, since the Link Object explicitly names the parameters and response body properties that
it can supply values for.
One advantage of allowing a backlink on the parameter object is that it could be specified on a parameter definition in components.parameters and then used by any operation that references this parameter. With links specified on the operation, the link will need to be added on every consuming operation.
A futher consideration is that Parameter Objects may be going away in OpenAPI v4, in favor of parameters defined using JSON schema. This would require extending the OpenAPI dialect of JSON schema to add a links attribute. But we don't want to support links everywhere in JSON schema -- just for parameters (and maybe request bodies), so this might be tricky.
The current structure for the links field in the OpenAPI v3 Response Object, and proposed here for the Operation Object,
is a Map[string, Link Object \| Reference Object], where the keys of this map are the "short name for the link". This short name has no real purpose in the API definition and just adds verbosity. A better structure would be [Link Object \| Reference Object] -- the equivalent of the values of the current map structure.
I didn't make this change to minimize the changes from the current structure, but it is appealing (to me at least) and perhaps we should reconsider.
One case that is not addressed by this proposal is extracting paired items from a list in the response.
A common case in Azure is a list operation for resources, where each entry in the list contains 1) an id field, and 2) an etag field. We'd like to be able to define a link that would say "You can call delete for a resource using the id and etag fields from any entry in the response of the list resources operation".
I've never understood HATEOAS. The notion of "just follow this link" with no definition of its parameters, headers, authorization scheme, response schema, response headers, etc does not make sense to me. I'm probably misrepresenting the concept of HATEOAS there but that's just the way it seems to me.
So you are correct that my proposal does not address excluding the paths used in links from the API definition. I think they should be in the API definition so that all the details of the request are well defined.