thread-local version of with-redefs

with-local-redefs.clj

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
;; Commentary                                                            ;;
;;                                                                       ;;
;; The goal for writing this started with the idea to have tests run in  ;;
;; parallel using the leiningen plugin eftest                            ;;
;; https://github.com/weavejester/eftest.                                ;;
;;                                                                       ;;
;; With tests using with-redefs, it was not possible to run them in      ;;
;; parallel if they were changing the root binding of the same           ;;
;; vars. Here, we are binding the root of the var to one function that   ;;
;; respects per-thread rebindings, if any exist.                         ;;
;;                                                                       ;;
;; Known caveats:                                                        ;;
;; - This per-therad rebinding will only work with clojure concurrency   ;;
;;   primitives which copy per-thread bindings to newly spawned threads, ;;
;;   eg, using clojure futures. But will not work for, say a             ;;
;;   java.lang.Thread.                                                   ;;
;; - As of now this only supports functions being bound and not other    ;;
;;   vars which store values, say (def x 19) for example.                ;;
;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;



(def ^:dynamic local-redefinitions {})

(defn current->original-definition
  [v]
  (when (var? v)
    (get (meta v) ::original)))


(defn redefiniton-fn
  [a-var]
  (fn [& args]
    (let [current-f (get local-redefinitions
                         a-var
                         (current->original-definition a-var))]
      (apply current-f args))))


(defn dynamic-redefs
  [vars func]
  (let [un-redefs (remove #(::already-bound? (meta %)) vars)]
    (doseq [a-var un-redefs]
      (locking a-var
        (when-not (::already-bound? (meta a-var))
          (let [old-val (.getRawRoot ^clojure.lang.Var a-var)]
            (.bindRoot ^clojure.lang.Var a-var
                       (redefiniton-fn a-var))
            (alter-meta! a-var
                         (fn [m]
                           (assoc m
                                  ::already-bound? true
                                  ::original old-val))))))))
  (func))


(defn xs->map
  [xs]
  (reduce (fn [acc [k v]] (assoc acc `(var ~k) v))
          {}
          (partition 2 xs)))


(defmacro with-dynamic-redefs
  [bindings & body]
  ;; @TODO: Add support for non-functions
  (let [map-bindings (xs->map bindings)]
    `(let [old-rebindings# local-redefinitions]
       (binding [local-redefinitions (merge old-rebindings# ~map-bindings)]
         (dynamic-redefs ~(vec (keys map-bindings))
                         (fn [] ~@body))))))



(comment ;; for testing
  (defn funk [& args] {:original-args args})
  (dotimes [i 1000]
    (let [f1 (future (with-dynamic-redefs [funk (constantly -100)]
                       (Thread/sleep (rand-int 10))
                       {:100 (funk) :t (.getName (Thread/currentThread))}))

          f2 (future (with-dynamic-redefs [funk (constantly -200)]
                       (Thread/sleep (rand-int 1000))
                       {:200 (funk 9) :t (.getName (Thread/currentThread))}))
          f3 (future (do
                       (Thread/sleep (rand-int 1000))
                       {:orig (funk 9) :t (.getName (Thread/currentThread))}))]
      (when (or (not= (:100 @f1) -100)
                (not= (:200 @f2) -200)
                (not= (:orig @f3) {:original-args '(9)}))
        (println "FAIL")
        (prn @f1)
        (prn @f2)
        (println "----------------\n\n")))))

This works fine.

(ns ptesttrial.core-test
  (:require [clojure.test :refer :all]
            [ptesttrial.core :as pc]))

(defmacro with-dynamic-redefs
  [bindings & body]  
  (let [vars (map (fn [x] `(var ~x)) (take-nth 2 bindings))]
    (doall (map #(.setDynamic (eval %)) vars))
    `(binding  ~bindings ~@body)))

(deftest b-test
  (is (= 99 (pc/funk 99)))
  (with-dynamic-redefs [pc/funk (constantly -1)]
    (is (= -1 (pc/funk 99)))))

Any reason for not doing this. Problem with your approach is setDynamic was not run during compilation so compiler emitted getRawRoot at call site (https://github.com/clojure/clojure/blob/b19b781b1f0f3f46aee5e951f415e0456a39cbcb/src/jvm/clojure/lang/Compiler.java#L5191). deftest put content of body in function which don't get invoked during compilation where as use of
defmacro make it run at compile.

@mourjo Just had this issue pop up on us. Thanks for sharing!

@rdivyanshu was trying to use your macro as a drop-in replacement to with-redefs, but think I've hit a problem.

The direct invocation usage works great:

(defn get-thing []
  :none)

;; fails, usually
(deftest with-redefs-not-thread-safe
  (let [results (pmap (fn [i]
                        (with-redefs [get-thing (constantly i)]
                          (get-thing)))
                      (range 100))]
    (is (= (range 100) results))))

(defmacro with-dynamic-redefs
  [bindings & body]
  (let [vars (map (fn [x] `(var ~x)) (take-nth 2 bindings))]
    (doall (map #(.setDynamic (eval %)) vars))
    `(binding  ~bindings ~@body)))

;; doesn't seem to fail?
(deftest with-dynamic-redefs-is-thread-safe
  (let [results (pmap (fn [i]
                        (with-dynamic-redefs [get-thing (constantly i)]
                          (get-thing)))
                      (range 100))]
    (is (= (range 100) results))))

But if I add indirection, it won't work until I re-evaluate the caller:

(defn get-thing []
  :none)

(defn get-indirect-thing []
  (get-thing))

;; fails, usually
(deftest with-redefs-not-thread-safe
  (let [results (pmap (fn [i]
                        (with-redefs [get-thing (constantly i)]
                          (get-indirect-thing)))
                      (range 100))]
    (is (= (range 100) results))))

(defmacro with-dynamic-redefs
  [bindings & body]
  (let [vars (map (fn [x] `(var ~x)) (take-nth 2 bindings))]
    (doall (map #(.setDynamic (eval %)) vars))
    `(binding  ~bindings ~@body)))

;; fails too
(deftest with-dynamic-redefs-is-thread-safe
  (let [results (pmap (fn [i]
                        (with-dynamic-redefs [get-thing (constantly i)]
                          (get-indirect-thing)))
                      (range 100))]
    (is (= (range 100) results))))

;; evaluating the caller again will make the test work
(defn get-indirect-thing []
  (get-thing))

;; now it doesn't fail
(deftest with-dynamic-redefs-is-thread-safe
  (let [results (pmap (fn [i]
                        (with-dynamic-redefs [get-thing (constantly i)]
                          (get-indirect-thing)))
                      (range 100))]
    (is (= (range 100) results))))

It looks like the same class of problem as before: callers that were defined before the macro runs get a non-dynamic version of the var.

For whoever finds this, the author actually made a lib that works with my example above: https://github.com/mourjo/dynamic-redef

@filipesilva It is happening due to there is no dynamic invocation of function get-thing. In get-indirect-thing you are invoking during definition. if you define get-indirect-thing according to below

(defn get-indirect-thing [f]
  (f))

And then call (get-indirect-thing get-thing) test passes. What you want in get-indirect-thing at run time is call current definition of get-thing but it is calling get-thing at time of definition. I am not sure if clojure provides such mechanism for functions with no arguments, it has been long since I wrote clojure code.

Hey thanks for getting back to me, wasn't expecting it at all :D

https://github.com/mourjo/dynamic-redef seems to handle the indirection case well so trying it out atm.

Thanks for this! Trying to understand this code - how are redefs reset when you go out of scope of the macro? looks like the var is permanently changed?

Yes the var is permanently changed. That is probably a good enough reason to only use this in tests. How it works is: the redefined var uses a dynamic (thread local) var to store local redefinitions.

As an aside: You might want to check out this repository (created based on this gist): https://github.com/mourjo/dynamic-redef

Ah okay. Would you accept a PR to have it remove itself once done, if I do that? (to the repo that is).
For my workflow permanently changing it means the changes leak out into my local dev env.

Absolutely, I would love your contribution!