Just documenting docs, articles, and discussion related to gRPC and load balancing.
https://github.com/grpc/grpc/blob/master/doc/load-balancing.md
Seems gRPC prefers thin client-side load balancing where a client gets a list of connected clients and a load balancing policy from a "load balancer" and then performs client-side load balancing based on the information. However, this could be useful for traditional load banaling approaches in clound deployments.
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/grpc-io/8s7UHY_Q1po
gRPC "works" in AWS. That is, you can run gRPC services on EC2 nodes and have them connect to other nodes, and everything is fine. If you are using AWS for easy access to hardware then all is fine. What doesn't work is ELB (aka CLB), and ALBs. Neither of these support HTTP/2 (h2c) in a way that gRPC needs. ELBs work in TCP mode, but you give up useful health checking and the join-shortest-queue behaviour that makes normal HTTP mode ELBs good. It also means you may experience problems with how well balanced your cluster is since only individual client connections are balanced rather than individual requests to the backend. If a single client is generating a lot of requests, they will all go to the same backend rather than being balanced across your available instances. This also means that ECS doesn't really work properly since it only supports the use of ELB and ALB load balancers. If your requirements are not too demanding TCP mode ELBs do work, and you can definitely ship stuff that way. It's just not ideal and has some fairly major problems as your request rates and general system complexity increase
I use gRPC on AWS and it works great. However, I don't believe ALBs support trailers in the HTTP/2 spec, so that won't work. Something may have changed since the last time I looked, but don't count on an HTTP/2 ALB working. I believe it's HTTP/2 to clients of the ELB but HTTP/1.1 to your backend servers.
Alternatively use ELB/ALB at Layer-3 but put your own HTTP2 compliant proxy behind it (Envoy, nghttpx, Linkerd, Traefik, ...) I know Lyft does this in production with Envoy.
https://forums.aws.amazon.com/thread.jspa?messageID=749377
We're trying to get the Application Load Balancer cooperating with some ECS-hosted gRPC services. So far it's failing; poking at the server a bit, it looks like requests are coming from the load balancer as HTTP/1.1, while gRPC server is expecting HTTP/2. The info on the load balancer suggests it supports HTTP/2, but does that only apply to the client side?
Hi. Yes, the requests are sent from the load balancer to the targets as HTTP/1.1. For more information, see http://docs.aws.amazon.com/elasticloadbalancing/latest/application/load-balancer-listeners.html#listener-configuration.
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/grpc-io/rgJ7QyecPoY
We sort of have this situation, since we use Google App Engine, and its load balancer and URLFetch service only support HTTP/1.1. We used the PRPC implementation described here, which is a mapping of the simple unary gRPC requests to an HTTP/1.1 protocol: http://nodir.io/post/138899670556/prpc. We used the Go implementation from the Chrome tools repository, and wrote our own client and server, which were relatively simple but absolutely do not support all of gRPC's features. The "better" approach might be to look at the grpc-web work, and possibly just run the grpcwebproxy. See: https://github.com/improbable-eng/grpc-web I think that will also have the problem that if your clients aren't Go or Javascript, you will need to implement the protocol yourself.
We normally recommend using a proxy that supports HTTP/2 to the backend, like nghttpx and derivatives (Envoy, Istio). If that's not possible, then the solutions tend to involve something that looks like grpc-web. If the proxy you are already using supports HTTP/1.1 trailers, it should be possible to use nghttpx to up-convert back to HTTP/2, but I've not tried that out.
https://making.lyst.com/2017/01/13/microservices/
HTTP load-balancing on gRPC services:
Using Envoy to Load Balance gRPC Traffic:
https://blog.bugsnag.com/envoy/
nginx now supports gRPC:
https://www.nginx.com/blog/nginx-1-13-10-grpc
gRPC Load Balancing with Nginx:
https://medium.com/@alextan/grpc-load-balancing-with-nginx-673d5d4df708
DNS Load Balancing in GRPC: