Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@simonholm
Created June 5, 2025 06:20
Show Gist options
  • Save simonholm/572286e27721f9fb53d4c6243892256a to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save simonholm/572286e27721f9fb53d4c6243892256a to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
MTB brand comparison: future-proof vs budget

MTB Brand and Model Comparison β€” Future-Proofing vs Budget

🚫 Why Trek Marlin is Not Future-Proof

Limitation Explanation
Non-Boost (141 mm QR) Not compatible with 12-speed MTB drivetrains
Quick-release axle Outdated β€” most upgrades require thru-axle
Entry-level drivetrain (8–10 speed) Limited upgrade path
No UDH / Di2 routing Not ready for wireless/electronic future
Narrow tire/frame clearance Less room for modern trail tires

Marlin is fine for casual use or light commuting, but not ideal if planning long-term upgrades or serious trail riding.


βœ… What Makes a Bike Future-Proof?

Feature Reason
Boost spacing (148 mm rear) Required for modern drivetrains
12-speed drivetrain (MicroSpline) Compatibility with current/upcoming cassettes
Internal cable routing / Di2-ready ports Clean install for upgrades
UDH (Universal Derailleur Hanger) Enables SRAM Transmission & modern setups
Threaded bottom bracket Easier maintenance and swaps
Hydraulic disc brakes Standardized, upgrade-friendly
Modern geometry (longer reach, slacker head angle) Better trail handling and suspension setup

🚲 Recommended Future-Proof Trek Models

Model Type Notes Price (SEK)
Trek Roscoe 8 Trail hardtail 12-speed, Boost, modern geo ~16β€―000–18β€―000
Trek X-Caliber 9 XC hardtail Race-ready, 12s-ready ~14β€―000–17β€―000
Trek Fuel EX 8 Full suspension Trail bike, Di2-compatible ~38β€―000–45β€―000
Trek Top Fuel 8 Full suspension XC Lightweight, 12s, UDH ~38β€―000–43β€―000

❌ Bianchi MTB: Premium Price, Lower Value

Issue Details
Expensive for spec You pay for branding, not component value
Road-focused brand MTB line-up not as optimized or widespread
Limited modularity Some frames not suited for upgrades (e.g., axle, BB standards)

Bianchi is beautiful but not cost-effective in MTB unless aesthetics or brand prestige is a priority.


πŸ’Έ Better Value Brands (for Swedish Riders)

Brand Notable Models Notes
Rockrider (Decathlon) XC500, 540S, 920 Great value, 12s-ready, internal routing
Merida Big Nine 600+, One-Twenty Often Boost + threaded BB, underrated
Marin Bobcat Trail, San Quentin Trail-focused, modern geo, affordable
Canyon (online) Grand Canyon, Neuron High-spec, great value, online direct
Polygon Xtrada, Siskiu Good spec/cost ratio, available online
Specialized Rockhopper, Chisel Higher price, quality frame design

πŸ”š Summary

If you're thinking of upgrading over time or want flexibility:

  • Avoid Trek Marlin β€” upgrade ceiling is low.
  • Consider Trek Roscoe/X-Caliber, Rockrider XC500, or Marin for value and future-proofing.
  • Skip Bianchi unless you're buying with your heart, not your toolkit.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment