Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@tgvashworth
Last active December 17, 2015 06:28
Show Gist options
  • Save tgvashworth/5565325 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save tgvashworth/5565325 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Why?

Why are am I here? Why am I alive, on this planet, at this time?

A big question? No, a deepity. In one reading, truth. In another, nonsense.

The word ‘why’ can be taken in two ways: why meaning for what purpose did x happen; and why meaning how did x happen. Let's look at ‘why am I here?’ from both perspectives.

In the first sense, the question can be rewritten as ‘for what purpose am I here?’. In the second, ‘how is it that I came to be here?’.

The latter is simple – evolution by natural selection, predicated by the appearance of self-replicating molecules. Evolution is a fact as much as gravity is a fact, and while the steps in the emergence of life on this planet (or indeed any other) is not yet understood, the creation of the raw materials necessary for life has been demonstrable in the lab for 60 years.

I'm not a biologist, and am therefore ill-placed to give a comprehensive presentation of the evidence, but a good read of scientific literature, or Wikipedia, will get you to roughly what I've described.

So it can be said that we know how it is that you or I came to be here.

The former question, ‘for what purpose am I here’ where the purpose is evident prior to your being, is non-sensical, and therefore not an answerable question. It is equivalent to asking ‘for what purpose are there mountains?‘. Mountains have no purpose, they simply are. Asking of their purpose cannot be answered, and so it is with humans. We simply are.

Notice also that the question is not the same as ‘to what end should I live my life?’. That is an entirely different, moral question that can be answered in many ways, and it is up to each and every person to answer it for themselves.

Asking the purpose of your being, as if it is somehow pre-ordained, is non-sensical. And so it is with all why questions, where why is taken to mean a universally directed purpose.

Why are mountains? Why is there sky? Indeed, why is there suffering?

@phuu.

@charm123
Copy link

Cool story bro.

@tgvashworth
Copy link
Author

@charm123 Thanks! I worked hard on it. And I'm flattered you joined Github just to say that... the effort is much appreciated. There simply aren't enough people like you offering supportive comments in this community. Solidarity, ‘bro’.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment