A few thoughts below about this anonymous person threatening two female academics in my area. Roopsha for complaining about discrimination at Perdue where she was denied tenure (for speaking up?) and Talia for vocally supporting her.
I think this person is awful and feel for both Roopsha and Talia for receiving such threats. Opinion aside, they are pointing to potential problems in the tenure system and potential harms that can come from complaining about sexism and discrimination.
This could be valuable information. From an information theoretic perspective, information identifying the reasons for systems not to operate as we want them is valuable in learning how to improve the systems. With that said, what are the shortages this person identified?
First, they are describing a potentially problematic structure communities that can cause major harm in speaking up. Namely, small communities with lots of friendships (conflicts of interest) and how in such structure criticising powerful entities could result